My sister doesn’t want her sons to know she has cancer

My sister is 72 and was diagnosed on Christmas Eve with stage 4 non small cell lung cancer with 3 brain metastases. This came completely out of the blue, I found her the previous day at home very confused and having hallucinations and called an ambulance, a chest X-ray showed the lung tumour and CT scan of chest and brain confirmed the diagnosis. Only the previous weekend we had been out together and although I had thought for a few weeks she seemed a little vague, her diagnosis was a terrible shock.

She is now living with me and my husband as we didn’t want her going back to the house where she had such frightening hallucinations, and she has quickly become very frail and dependant so there is no question of her living alone again. We’re glad to have her with us where she can be safe and comfortable and I’m taking leave from work to look after her. She is due to start 10 sessions of whole brain radiotherapy on 8 Feb , Palliative only.

although she has named me as her next of kin, she does have 2 sons. One lives not far away and she has had no contact with him for 14 years, since he came to my own son’s 30th birthday party. The other lives about 60 miles away and has not seen her for 10 years, although they occasionally talk on the phone. She has at least 5 grandchildren, none of whom keep in touch either, and 3 great grand children. I’ve tried in the past to bring her back together with her eldest, but he backed out. Their differences date back many years to when she split up from their dad. The loss of contact has hurt her enormously over the years as when she was married to her second husband they spent a lot of time and money helping one to overcome alcoholism and the other with financial problems, but now she is divorced again and on her own they don’t want to know her.

I don’t want to make her situation sound too bad because she is a very valued part of my family, and is included in all our celebrations and day to day activities, and we often go on holiday together. My sons and grandchildren love her and have all been very supportive through this nightmare. My problem is she refuses to let me tell her sons she is ill, I asked her as soon as she got her diagnosis, her answer was a definite NO and although I ask her regularly in case she changes her mind, the answer is always the same. She’s also said the same to the Macmillan nurse and the Palliative Care Nurse from our local hospice. I have promised to abide by her wishes because I think that in a situation where she has lost almost every shred of control over her life, in this she does have control and I must respect it. If I went against her wishes I think she would never trust me again.

i just wondered if anyone else has had the same dilemma, and might have some words of advice for me.

  • Hi there ... as difficult as it is for you, in my mind they have had many chances over the years to love the mum / nan as you and yours do .. l think she needs you now as you have been there through thick and thin ... if they have not cared for so many years , l would feel the same as her .. you need people that really love you around at a time like this .. 

    I'm sorry if that sounds harsh, as I'm always one who says "make up for time lost with your kids" but this sinario is different as she has said all along , no more .. and it could make matters worse and add to her stress if they showed up now .. you could always tell her , if ever she changes her mind you'll do it then .. how wonderfull she has an amazing sister in you .. so sending you a big virtual hug ...

  • Hello nannypaddy.  Bless you, your part of the family sounds like a proper family should be and you have taken on the care for  your beloved sister.    I think you are absolutely right to go along with her wishes.

    I probably don't need to mention this - and I suppose it is not part of this website - but please protect yourself from accusations of putting pressure on her not to contact her sons when she was terminally ill. It is of course good that the nurses know that this is not the case.  I know it appears to be a ridiculous accusation but things can get nasty particularly where money may be concerned.  I am not asking for any details!  I just would hate your regard for your sister to be misinterpreted this way.  Sorry, I and my unpleasant thoughts will disappear now. Enjoy the time you have  with your sister.