Ethnic minority women face more barriers to seeing their GP
Women from ethnic minority backgrounds* report around twice as many barriers** than white women to seeking help for potential cancer symptoms, according to new research funded by Cancer Research UK.
The study published in Psycho-Oncology found that, in England, women from ethnic minority backgrounds were more likely to feel too embarrassed to talk to a GP (75-91%) than white women (8%). Being too scared that a symptom was a sign of something serious was also more likely to be a potential barrier for ethnic minority groups.
And those with a poor understanding of what the GP says were around three times less likely to feel confident to talk in a consultation.
The researchers, based at the University of Surrey and Kings College London, surveyed 720 women from six different ethnic groups in England (white, Caribbean, African, Indian, Pakistani and Bangladeshi), to try and understand why women might delay seeking medical help.
Participants were asked to answer how strongly they agreed with 11 statements designed to assess potential barriers to going to a GP if they had symptoms***, as well as answering some additional questions on their health literacy level and fatalistic beliefs.
Fatalism (i.e. having strong views on things such as “when bad things happen, it’s because they were meant to be” or “people die when it’s their time, and nothing can change that”) was higher among ethnic minority women compared with white women. And having a strong fatalistic belief was associated with reduced body awareness. This could mean that some women may be less likely to get to know their bodies.
The researchers also discovered that ethnic minority women who had moved to the UK as adults were around 40 % less likely to report worrying about wasting a GP’s time as a potential barrier, than women from the same ethnic background born in the UK. This could suggest that a ‘stiff upper lip’ is engrained in British society and exists for women born in the UK, but is not usually adopted by women who move here later in life.
Across the groups, around 30% of ethnic minority women (except Bangladeshi) said they would pray about a symptom compared with 10% of white women, but it is not known whether they would pray instead of going to the doctor or pray alongside going to the doctor.
African, Indian, Pakistani and Bangladeshi women were also more likely to say they might use traditional remedies, but again, it is not known whether they would do that instead of, or as well as, going to the doctor.
Some previous studies**** have shown varied cancer outcomes exist across different ethnic groups. This could mean, due to perceiving more barriers, ethnic minority women may postpone seeking medical help which can delay cancer treatment and reduce survival.
Dr Katriina Whitaker, from the University of Surrey, said: “We found that women from different ethnic backgrounds experienced different barriers to seeking help. Often studies aren’t fully representative of the population, so including people from different ethnic backgrounds in research is an important step in identifying how to reduce inequalities.
“By addressing the barriers present in different communities, we have an opportunity to implement changes that can make everyone feel able to access healthcare. Only then will everyone have the best chance of surviving their cancer.”
Dr Julie Sharp, Cancer Research UK’s head of health and patient information, said: “The earlier stage a cancer is diagnosed at, the better chance people have of surviving their disease. So we urge people to tell their doctor if they notice any changes to their body that aren’t normal for them.
“Making sure ethnic minority women are aware of things that can be done to make a doctor’s appointment easier, such as the use of translation services, will hopefully give them the confidence to speak openly to their GP about any concerns. At Cancer Research UK, our roadshow goes out into different communities to provide information about cancer and our online cancer chat forum provides a safe space for people to share their experiences and give support. *****
“It’s understandable that symptoms can be scary, embarrassing or something that’s hard to talk about. But doctors are there to help and are used to dealing with things patients may find difficult to discuss. In most cases it won’t be cancer, but it’s best to get it checked out.”
For media enquiries please contact the Cancer Research UK press office on +44 203 469 8300 or, out-of-hours, the duty press officer on +44 7050 264 059.
Williams ED., Whitaker KL., Piano M, Marlow L.A.V. (2019) Ethnic differences in barriers to symptomatic presentation in primary care: A survey of women in England, Psycho-Oncology, DOI: 10.1002/pon.5225
Notes to Editor
We work closely with Community Links who have been commissioned by the NHS in a number of areas across London to contact non-responders to screening programmes – using health facilitators who are recruited from the local community, speak the same language and understand the local barriers to participation.
*In England the ethnic minority population includes anyone who self-identifies as being from an ethnic group other than white. While this population is extremely diverse, just over half are represented within five ethnic groups: Caribbean, African, Indian, Pakistani and Bangladeshi which is why these 5 groups were included in the study
**White women report on average 3 barriers, whereas ethnic minority women report an average of about 6 (when combined) – Table 2, bottom row: total number of barriers out of 11
***Participants were asked about potential barriers they might face to visiting a GP if they had symptoms. They were asked to rate the 11 statements from “strongly agree” to “strongly disagree.”
****Copson, E. et al. Ethnicity and outcome of young breast cancer patients in the United Kingdom: The POSH study. Br. J. Cancer (2014). doi:10.1038/bjc.2013.650
*****Cancer Research UK has a range of resource for people if they need more information or feel unable to talk with their loved ones:
- Our cancer roadshows go out into different communities and have useful information about cancer risk, screening, early diagnosis and prevention.
- Our cancer chat forum provides a safe space where people can talk about their experience, share their concerns and gain support from other people in the same situation https://www.cancerresearchuk.org/welcome-to-cancer-chat?_ga=2.268288519.86274883.1572339714-2057798679.1548329990
- Our cancer nurses are available to talk on the phone anonymously for anyone who has any questions: 0808 800 4040 Monday to Friday, 9am to 5pm