Charity concerned for children as e-cigarette market flourishes
Celebrity endorsements and social media are attracting young people to use e-cigarettes according to a new report commissioned by Cancer Research UK released today* (Wednesday).
“The fact that multinational tobacco companies are moving in on this market is of particular concern - from past experience we know they are deceitful, determined and deeply detrimental to public health.”
- Professor Gerard Hastings, University of Stirling
The charity is calling for children to be protected from unregulated marketing of these products. But Cancer Research UK does not want e-cigarettes to be banned and sees their potential to help smokers to quit.
Researchers analysed nearly 1000 individual pieces of marketing collected over 13 months. They found a long list of marketing techniques such as online promotions that use competitions, apps on mobile phones and group discount vouchers for e-cigarettes – all likely to appeal to young people.
Alison Cox, Cancer Research UK’s head of tobacco policy, said: “Tobacco cigarettes cause one in four cancer deaths. Hundreds of children start smoking every day and we don’t want the marketing of e-cigarettes to confuse the message that smoking kills.
“We aren’t opposed to e-cigarettes being marketed to adult smokers – and hope that the marketing effort encourages many smokers to give up.
“There’s evidence in the report - particularly on social media - of e-cigs being promoted as cool and the latest thing and applying all the kinds of marketing ploys that would be used to attract a youth market including involving pop stars, computer games and one e-cig company even sponsoring a football youth team’s strip.”
Without clear regulation on how e-cigarettes can be marketed, manufacturers are advertising on TV, billboards, buses, online, in computer games and in magazines as well as using a range of cosmetic touches such as colourful and innovative packaging and flavours such as strawberry, apple and cherry that give their products appeal to young people.
Sponsorship for a range of sports including motor and power boat racing was also highlighted as a prominent promotional strategy used by a number of independent e-cigarette companies.
E-cigarettes are described as being promoted on the way to exclusive events such as Glastonbury, busy locations like Canary Wharf, on company websites, specialist shops, concessions and e-lounges where people can buy and ‘smoke’ e-cigarettes.
For young non-smokers and social smokers, e-cigarettes are positioned as socially attractive and part of a rapidly growing trend.
The report also raises serious concerns that the tobacco industry will use e-cigarettes to gain access to politicians and public health policy makers, and gaining influence and respectability.
Professor Gerard Hastings, report co-author at the University of Stirling, said: “E-cigarettes and other alternative nicotine delivery devices are probably much safer than conventional cigarettes, and so if smokers switch to them many lives could be saved.
“But the market is looking to make money, not improve public health, and this is creating many dangers. The fact that multinational tobacco companies are moving in on this market is of particular concern - from past experience we know they are deceitful, determined and deeply detrimental to public health. E-cigarettes could provide them with the cover they need to regain the powerful position they once had - in which case a Trojan horse will rapidly become a Trojan hearse.”
Cancer Research UK has welcomed the news that there will also be a public consultation on e-cigarette marketing in 2014 by the Committees of Advertising Practice to decide what level of advertising controls are needed.
Alison Cox added: “It’s too long to wait until 2016 when e-cigarettes are due to fall under medical licensing regulation that might help to address these concerns. The government should move faster.”
Dr Marisa de Andrade, report author based at the University of Stirling, said: “E-cigarette marketing has grown exponentially in the UK over the last 18 months. The tobacco industry’s increasing interest in this market and attempts to engage with policy makers and the public health community are a major concern.
“We need to ensure these ‘next generation products’ do not usher in the next generation of smokers – an e-cigarette advert recently appeared in an iPad children's game. These are worrying developments and swift action is needed.”
For media enquiries contact the Cancer Research UK press office on 020 3469 8300 or, out of hours, on 07050 264 059.
Notes to Editor
Download a full copy of the report here.
British American Tobacco was the first major tobacco group to buy a British e-cig company - CN Creative who make Intellicig, with others following. Lorillard now own e-cig company Blu, and Altria - owners of Philip Morris and the Marlboro brand - is launching its own e-cig brand.
The Medicines and Healthcare Products Regulatory Agency (MHRA) ruled in June this year that all nicotine-containing products (NCPs), such as electronic cigarettes, are to be regulated as medicines in a move to ensure the safety of these products, and stop the sale and marketing to under 18s. Due to come into force in 2016, this decision is now under threat since the EU parliament voted against similar Europe-wide measures.
Negotiations are taking place at the EU level on 16 December when the fate of e-cigarette marketing across Europe will be decided.